
What Is a Good Faith Violation? Cash Account Rules Explained
Learn what a good faith violation is, how T+1 trade settlement works in cash accounts, and how to avoid freezes. Read the full guide.
By Trader Faculty Team
Direct Answer
A good faith violation occurs in a cash brokerage account when you buy a security with unsettled sale proceeds and sell that newly bought security before the original sale finishes clearing. At many brokers, including Fidelity, three violations in a rolling 12-month period restrict your account to settled-cash purchases for 90 calendar days.
This rule is broken in a cash trading account when you buy a security using unsettled sale proceeds and then sell that newly purchased security before the original cash settles.
Many beginners run into this rule when they sell one stock and immediately jump into another trade on the same day. Seeing buying power in your account can make it feel like the cash is ready to use without limits, until a sudden broker warning pops up. This guide breaks down how trade settlement works, how the rule gets triggered step by step, and how you can keep your account free from restrictions.
Quick Takeaways
- It takes two actions: buying a stock with unsettled funds and selling that exact position before the original sale settles.
- Most U.S. stock and ETF trades settle on a T+1 cycle, which means your cash finishes clearing one business day after the trade date.
- Brokers such as Fidelity restrict a cash account to settled-cash purchases for 90 calendar days after three violations in a rolling 12-month period.
- Checking your "Settled Cash" balance instead of total buying power before short-term trades prevents accidental violations.
What Is a Good Faith Violation?
A good faith violation (GFV) is a cash-account violation that happens when you sell a security you bought with unsettled funds before the cash from your earlier sale has settled.
When you trade in a cash account, every stock or exchange-traded fund (ETF) order goes through two stages: execution and settlement. Execution is when your order fills on the market, and settlement is the official transfer of shares to the buyer and cash to the seller. Under U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) settlement rules, most U.S. stock and ETF trades settle on a T+1 cycle, meaning trade date plus one business day.
Brokers often let you buy a new stock right away using the money from a stock you just sold, even though that cash hasn't settled yet. Federal Reserve Regulation T lets a broker allow this when it accepts, in good faith, your agreement to pay in full before you sell. If you sell that new stock early, you've broken that agreement.
Keep in mind that this rule applies only to cash accounts. Margin accounts work differently because you can borrow from your broker, though margin brings borrowing costs and extra risks of its own.
How This Violation Happens (Step-by-Step T+1 Example)
This rule is broken only when you complete both halves of the cycle: buying with unsettled cash and selling that new position before T+1 settlement finishes.
Suppose you start Monday morning with $2,000 of fully settled cash in your brokerage cash account. Here's how the next few trades play out under current T+1 rules:
- Monday, 10:00 AM: You buy $2,000 worth of Stock A using your settled cash.
- Monday, 1:00 PM: You sell all of Stock A for $2,000. Your broker updates your buying power to $2,000, but those proceeds are unsettled cash until Tuesday (T+1).
- Monday, 2:30 PM: You use that $2,000 of unsettled cash to buy Stock B. At this point, you haven't broken any rule. Buying with unsettled proceeds is allowed in a cash account.
- Monday, 3:45 PM (Violation): You sell Stock B before the market closes. Because you sold Stock B before Monday's sale of Stock A settled on Tuesday, your broker records a violation.
What if you held Stock B overnight and sold it on Tuesday morning instead? Once Monday's sale settles on Tuesday, your cash is cleared, so selling Stock B on Tuesday or later doesn't trigger a violation.
Good Faith Violation vs. Free Riding Violation
A GFV happens when you sell a security you bought with unsettled sale proceeds. A free riding violation occurs when you buy a security without enough cash and sell that same security to pay for it.
Both rules protect brokers from unpaid trades, yet they work differently and carry different penalties. FINRA notes that free riding violates Federal Reserve Regulation T. A third rule, the cash liquidation violation, happens when you buy a security and then sell other fully paid holdings to cover the cost.
| Rule Type | What Triggers the Violation | Typical Broker Penalty (Fidelity) |
|---|---|---|
| Good Faith Violation (GFV) | Buying with unsettled sale proceeds and selling before settlement | 90-day settled-cash restriction after 3 violations in 12 months |
| Free Riding Violation | Buying with insufficient cash and selling that security to pay for it | 90-day settled-cash restriction after 1 violation in 12 months |
| Cash Liquidation Violation | Buying securities, then selling other fully paid holdings to cover the cost | 90-day settled-cash restriction after 3 violations in 12 months |
Notice how much stricter free riding is. At Fidelity, three GFVs trigger the restriction, but a single free riding violation does.
What Happens If You Break the Rule? (Including Fidelity Rules)
At many brokers, three violations within a rolling 12-month period restrict your cash account for 90 calendar days, which means you need settled cash upfront before placing any buy order.
FINRA describes this violation as buying a security with cash from a transaction that hasn't settled and then selling it before those proceeds settle. The 90-day penalty comes from broker policy, so read your own cash account agreement. At Fidelity, three violations in a 12-month period restrict your account to buying with settled cash for 90 calendar days.
Fidelity's learning center says a violation counts when you sell a security before paying for it in full with settled funds. Only cash or proceeds from fully paid securities qualify as settled funds. Fidelity also treats one free riding violation as enough to trigger the same restriction. Other brokers may count differently, so check your own agreement.
How to Avoid Cash Account Violations
You can prevent these violations by tracking your settled cash balance and waiting until T+1 settlement before selling positions funded by recent sales.
Follow these four practical habits to keep your cash account running smoothly:
- Check "Settled Cash" before trading: Ignore your total buying power if you plan to buy and sell on the same day. Use only the balance your broker labels as settled cash for intraday trades.
- Wait until T+1 to sell: If you buy a stock using unsettled proceeds from an earlier sale, plan to hold that new position at least until the next business day so the original cash settles.
- Keep a settled cash buffer: Keeping part of your account in settled cash gives you room to take a quick trade without touching unsettled proceeds from earlier sales.
- Weigh margin risks carefully before switching: Margin accounts don't use this rule, but they bring other costs. Switching adds loan interest, the risk of a margin call (a broker demand to add cash or sell holdings when equity falls too low), and intraday margin requirements with a minimum equity level.
Conclusion
Understanding how this rule works comes down to two simple habits: knowing the difference between execution and T+1 settlement, and checking your settled cash before exiting a quick trade. Keeping track of these rules helps protect your account from 90-day restrictions and builds steady discipline as you start trading in live markets. Trading always carries the risk of losing money, so treat everything in this guide as educational material for your own research rather than personal financial advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many good faith violations are allowed before an account is restricted?
That depends on your broker, but a common policy is three violations in a rolling 12-month period. At Fidelity, the third violation restricts your cash account to settled-cash purchases for 90 calendar days.
Do violations reset after 12 months?
In a rolling 12-month window, each violation counts for 12 months from its date, so your count drops one at a time rather than resetting all at once. Check your broker's policy for exact counting.
Can I buy stocks with unsettled funds without a violation?
Yes. Buying a stock or exchange-traded fund (ETF) with unsettled proceeds from a prior sale is allowed in a cash account. A violation happens only if you sell that newly purchased position before the cash from the earlier sale settles on T+1.
Do these violations apply to margin accounts or crypto?
No. The rule applies to cash brokerage accounts that trade securities such as stocks and ETFs. Margin accounts let you trade against unsettled balances with borrowed funds, but they bring margin interest costs, margin call risks, and intraday margin requirements. Crypto trades on a crypto exchange aren't covered by this securities cash-account rule.
What happens if I get a good faith violation on Fidelity?
At Fidelity, three violations in a 12-month period restrict your cash account to buying with settled cash for 90 calendar days. Fidelity's learning center says a violation counts when you sell a security before paying for it in full with settled funds.
Keep learning
Trading 101
Know the mechanics cold before you risk a single cent.
8 lessons quiz
Start Trading 101The Trader Faculty Team writes and reviews every guide together — pairing hands-on market experience with a curriculum-first approach to trading education. One good syllabus, taught in the order that makes you better.





